WHEN WAS LIBERAL BOURGEOISE VERDICT OF HISTORY RENDERED? 1640s 1680s 'Industrial Revolution' 1776 1789 1832 ?

"Exactly when 'the future' arrived was curiously vague....Some (historians) were frankly muddled about the date...."
Clark, Revolution and Rebellion, p 95

Same goes for the so called Enlightenment....  

Some historians think it is still going on! 

Trump, just a bad example of a modern enlightened despot!
FDR a good one!